Interview

Alex Epstein: bipartisan permitting reform (BAHA) is now-or-never with 15 days left on the congressional calendar

Nov 20, 2026 with Alex Epstein

Key Points

  • BAHA, the first comprehensive permitting reform to clear the Senate in 46 years, has 15 days on the congressional calendar before incoming committee leadership makes passage structurally impossible for six years.
  • House passage hinges entirely on Democratic Minority Leader Hakim Jeffries: active support unlocks a suspension procedure, while active whipping against the rule vote kills the bill despite Republican majorities.
  • The bill streamlines NEPA timelines, fixes Clean Water Act pipeline blocks, and reforms electricity transmission permitting, removing the primary infrastructure constraint on AI data center siting and natural gas pipeline capacity.
Alex Epstein: bipartisan permitting reform (BAHA) is now-or-never with 15 days left on the congressional calendar

Summary

BAHA permitting reform: 15 days to pass or lose it for six years

The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act — BAHA — just cleared the Senate 63-32, the first time comprehensive permitting reform has advanced this far in roughly 46 years. Alex Epstein, founder of the Center for Industrial Progress and one of the more active advocates on this issue, argues the window to finish the job is around 15 days on the congressional calendar. After that, the committee leadership of the incoming Congress makes passage essentially impossible.

Why the House is the problem

The Senate hurdle — 60 votes to break a filibuster — is typically the harder one. BAHA cleared it with 15 Democrat-aligned votes. The House requires only a simple majority, but that majority can't form unless a procedural rule vote first allows the bill to be introduced. That rule vote is where it dies if House Minority Leader Hakim Jeffries instructs Democrats to vote against it. Epstein says that if Jeffries actively whips against the rule, at most four Democrats would defy him. Republicans hold a narrow majority, meaning even a handful of absences — members who've already lost their seats and have no reason to show up — could sink it without Democratic cover.

The cleanest path is Jeffries actively supporting it, which would allow the bill to bypass the rule vote entirely under a suspension procedure. His minimum ask is that Jeffries simply doesn't whip against it.

“We have a situation where if we just take the AI piece of it... you do not increase our freedom to build, we forego endless opportunities, and we are gonna have catastrophic increases in prices. So that's one reason why finally Republicans and Democrats have gotten together and passed what's called comprehensive permitting reform... We're in the middle of it right now. We have fifteen days left on the congressional calendar. We either pass this or we're screwed on permitting reform for at least six years.”

What the bill actually does

BAHA reforms three structural bottlenecks. It significantly overhauls NEPA (the National Environmental Policy Act), which Epstein says is the main reason some domestic mining permits take over 20 years. It fixes Clean Water Act provisions that have been used to block natural gas pipelines on the basis of temporary construction turbidity — muddy water during the build, not contamination. And it addresses electricity transmission, trying to make necessary transmission easier to build while preventing utilities from forcing ratepayers to fund wasteful lines.

The bill is technology-neutral — it doesn't subsidize any specific energy source, which is what made bipartisan support possible. Republican senators Mike Lee and Shelley Capito anchored it on one side; Democratic senators Sheldon Whitehouse and Martin Heinrich on the other. Whitehouse's calculation, Epstein notes, is that solar and wind are competitive enough to win on a genuinely free market, so he's willing to liberate all energy permitting.

The amendment that didn't happen

Senate negotiators prepared a manager's amendment designed to address House concerns and broaden Republican support. Senators Jeff Merkley and Ron Wyden blocked it by denying unanimous consent. The result is that the House now faces a less favorable package, with more members willing to fight the rule vote.

Merkley's position matters beyond this procedural maneuver. He is the incoming chairman of the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee in the new Congress. Jared Huffman takes the House Natural Resources Committee. Both oppose anything resembling BAHA. That is why Epstein insists this is structurally now-or-never, not just tactically urgent — the committee leadership that made this deal possible won't be in those chairs next term.

The AI and energy infrastructure read

For the tech audience, Epstein's argument is direct: the most important infrastructure constraint on AI is natural gas pipeline capacity, not the gas itself. The U.S. and Canada have abundant supply. The bottleneck is moving it. Without permitting reform, data center siting gets pushed toward existing supply clusters, and power costs spike as demand from AI and general compute outpaces the freedom to build generation capacity.

The one provision Epstein flags as genuinely worse than the status quo for the industry is the data center cost-allocation clause. Under BAHA, data centers bear the full grid infrastructure costs they necessitate rather than sharing them with other ratepayers. The industry largely accepted this, Epstein says, partly because power is a meaningful but not dominant share of total project cost, and partly because speed-to-power matters more than marginal cost savings. His broader argument is that data centers are net fiscal windfalls for localities — concentrated taxable value in a small footprint, reducing property tax burdens and funding schools — and communities that block them will have FOMO when neighboring states capture that investment.

The ask

Republicans can pass this without a single Democratic vote if they all show up. The Freedom Caucus is the main risk on that side — Epstein is asking them to evaluate the bill against the status quo, not against an ideal bill that has no path forward in 15 days. On the Democratic side, the singular variable is Jeffries. Active support unlocks suspension. Silence or non-opposition is enough to let it through. Active whipping kills it.

Epstein says he's planning a permitting party once it passes. No party if it doesn't.

Every deal, every interview. 5 minutes.

TBPN Digest delivers summaries of the latest fundraises, interviews and tech news from TBPN, every weekday.