Interview

Eric Wind on the independent watchmaker bubble, super fakes, and 9,000 copies sold in week one

Nov 20, 2026 with Eric Wind

Key Points

  • Independent watchmakers exhibit bubble characteristics as young designers pre-sell allocations a decade out on interest-free deposits, with only about 20 sustainable at $500,000-plus valuations despite hundreds entering the market.
  • Wind Vintage moves upmarket to $20,000-plus watches partly to escape the super fake problem, which now targets modern Rolex so convincingly that the percentage of counterfeits on wrists is rising.
  • Wind's *Vintage Watches: The Modern Guide* sold 9,000 copies in week one, positioning the Wind Vintage founder as a category authority as he awaits New York Times bestseller status.
Eric Wind on the independent watchmaker bubble, super fakes, and 9,000 copies sold in week one

Summary

Eric Wind on vintage watches, the independent maker bubble, and 9,000 copies in week one

Eric Wind went from writing a Friday column on Hodinkee for $300 a piece to founding Wind Vintage with his wife in 2017, building off roughly 30,000 dedicated readers who followed him from the blog to Christie's and then into his own dealership. Within two months of leaving Christie's, he had made as much as he had in the entire previous year. The business has moved steadily upmarket since, now focused on watches priced at $20,000 and above.

“You can graduate watchmaking school at age 18 or 19, basically set up a website and an Instagram and have a few million dollars wired into your account within a day or two from independent collectors... These small watchmakers are literally selling out allocations a decade down... We've sold about 9,000 copies so far the first week.”

The independent watchmaker bubble

The sharpest part of the conversation is Wind's read on independent watchmakers. An F.P. Journe tourbillon — one of 20 originals — that Wind sold in 2021 for $950,000 just sold at auction in France for $11 million. Another is coming up in New York in weeks. Rexhep Rexhepi's watches retail around $80,000–$90,000 and resell for $4 million.

The economics feeding this are unusual. Young watchmakers graduating at 18 or 19 can post a CAD rendering on Instagram and have millions of dollars wired into their accounts within days. Many are pre-selling allocations a decade out, collecting one-third down — interest-free capital on watches they won't deliver until 2035 or 2036.

Wind thinks it has bubble characteristics. The allocation model functions more like a call option than a commitment: buyers put down a third, monitor whether the maker builds cultural weight, and decide whether to complete the purchase years later. The number of independents who can sustain $500,000-plus valuations is probably closer to 20 than 100. Some will go out of business; trends shift. Wind tells clients asking whether a young brand will survive until their allocation comes due that he genuinely doesn't know.

Chanel has already moved — it invested in F.P. Journe years ago and recently acquired Ybell, an eighties-era brand it appears to be positioning as an entry-level offering. Wind's view is that the larger Swiss groups are behind, and the smarter play would be to surface the named watchmakers inside their own organisations, creating brand-within-a-brand propositions where collectors can have a personal relationship with the person making their watch.

Super fakes and where Wind Vintage sits

Modern Rolex is the target. Super fakes are now close enough to the real thing that they're nearly indistinguishable on the wrist. Wind says the percentage of people wearing fake Rolex is rising, and it's a problem Rolex needs to confront directly.

Wind Vintage's decision to move upmarket is partly a structural defence against this. High-quality fakes of independent watchmakers barely exist. Patek, AP, and comparable vintage pieces are rarely replicated convincingly. The super fake problem is concentrated in mass-market modern Rolex — Batmans, Batgirls, standard GMTs — exactly the category Wind is deliberately moving away from.

The book

Wind's Vintage Watches: The Modern Guide sold roughly 9,000 copies in its first week. He describes it as a "quasi coffee table book" — substantial enough to read on a plane, visual enough to showcase the watches properly. He was waiting on New York Times bestseller list results for non-fiction at the time of this conversation.

Every deal, every interview. 5 minutes.

TBPN Digest delivers summaries of the latest fundraises, interviews and tech news from TBPN, every weekday.